The right auditor is the firm and engagement team that can meet your organisation’s requirements with appropriate capability, capacity and independent judgement. That may be a Big Four firm, a mid-tier firm or a specialist audit firm. The answer can also be to stay with your current auditor and improve how the engagement works.
If you are considering a change, start with what your business needs and the evidence each firm can provide. Neither a recognised name nor a promise of personal service is enough on its own.
Start with the business, not the category of firm
Define the requirements before comparing proposals: your group structure, reporting framework, sector, locations, deadlines and the expectations of shareholders, lenders and any group auditor. Consider what may change over the next few years, including acquisitions, overseas operations or investment.
Big Four, mid-tier and specialist are useful descriptions, but they are not uniform service specifications. Their capabilities overlap. A specialist firm may focus on particular sectors, reporting requirements or types of business; the description alone tells you little about its team size, resources or suitability. Ask what its specialism means for your engagement.
When a Big Four firm may be the right choice
A Big Four firm may be well suited where your organisation needs extensive international coordination, several specialist disciplines or experience of particularly complex transactions and reporting. Existing relationships across a group may also make coordination more effective.
Assess how those resources would actually support your audit. Which specialists are expected to contribute? Who coordinates overseas work? How will technical questions be resolved, and who will communicate the implications to your finance team? The value lies in the resources relevant to your organisation, rather than the breadth of services available in principle.
If your current team understands the business, delivers reliably and addresses significant matters well, there may be little reason to change. A review should allow that conclusion.
When to consider mid-tier or specialist audit firms
A mid-tier or specialist firm may be a suitable option where it can demonstrate the necessary technical expertise, sector understanding and delivery capacity. Some businesses value a particular team’s approach to communication, planning or senior involvement. Those qualities should be tested in every proposal, including one from a larger firm.
Ask who will perform and review the work, what support is available for complex issues and how the firm would cope if key team members became unavailable. Where international work is involved, establish how it would be coordinated and who would be accountable. Do not assume that either a network name or a smaller team guarantees the arrangement you need.
A firm should be willing to explain the limits of its capability and when additional expertise would be necessary. A clear explanation of those limits is more useful than a broad assurance that everything can be accommodated.
When staying and resetting expectations makes sense
Before beginning a selection process, discuss specific concerns with the engagement partner. Separate a recurring delivery problem from a difficult year, a change in reporting requirements or delays in providing information.
For example, if queries arrived late, examine when the underlying schedules were available, which issues were foreseeable and how the timetable was agreed. If senior input felt limited, identify the decisions on which you needed it and agree when that input should occur.
A revised timetable, clearer escalation arrangements or better preparation may resolve the issue. Give agreed improvements an owner and a review date. If material concerns remain unresolved, or the firm no longer has the capabilities your organisation requires, a wider review becomes more useful.
Compare evidence from the proposed teams
Use the same questions for the incumbent and prospective firms. Ask for specific arrangements rather than accepting general promises about responsiveness or partner access.
- Relevant experience: What comparable sectors, structures and reporting issues has the proposed team handled? How will that experience inform the audit?
- Technical support: Which specialist skills may be needed, how are they accessed and how are their costs reflected in the proposal?
- Capacity and continuity: Who is expected to work on the engagement, when is capacity available and how are changes in personnel managed?
- Senior involvement: At which stages will the partner and other senior team members participate? How are significant issues escalated?
- Delivery: What must each party provide, by when, and how will progress and outstanding matters be tracked?
- Quality: How does the firm supervise and review the work, address difficult judgements and learn from quality reviews?
- Stakeholder requirements: Can the proposed arrangement meet the requirements of shareholders, lenders and the group auditor?
Where appropriate, seek references from clients with comparable needs. Discuss delivery experience without expecting a firm to disclose confidential information about its clients.
Compare the scope behind the fee
Compare proposals on consistent assumptions. Identify which entities and reporting requirements are covered, the expected state of the records, any specialist involvement and the treatment of first-year work. Establish what could lead to additional fees and how these would be discussed.
A lower fee is not automatically better value, and a higher fee is not evidence of better quality. Consider the resources committed, the clarity of the scope and the demands on your finance team. Ask the incumbent to explain changes in its fee before assuming they reflect a change in service or priorities.
A challenging audit is not necessarily a poor audit
Questions about estimates, evidence or accounting treatments can be uncomfortable. That does not make them inappropriate. The assessment should distinguish the substance of a legitimate challenge from how clearly and promptly it was communicated.
Choosing an auditor should not be a way to avoid scrutiny or obtain a preferred accounting answer. A constructive relationship allows management and auditors to discuss difficult matters professionally while maintaining their separate responsibilities.
If you decide to change, plan the first year carefully
Discuss timing before committing to a move. Establish what the prospective firm needs to complete its acceptance process, how the formal appointment requirements will be addressed and what information it will need from management and the outgoing auditor.
Allow for first-year familiarisation, opening balances, group coordination and relevant inventory attendance. Ask who will manage the handover and what could affect the timetable. A change close to a reporting deadline may limit your options; a smooth transition should not be promised before the circumstances are understood.
For a fuller discussion, read Changing auditors: process, timing and first-year costs.
Does the business need a different auditor, or different support?
Weak forecasts, limited management reporting or uncertainty about growth do not necessarily mean the audit appointment is wrong. The business may need separately scoped financial or strategic support while retaining its auditor.
Consider those needs on their own merits. Where services are proposed alongside audit, their compatibility and the applicable independence requirements need assessment before acceptance. Management retains responsibility for its decisions and implementation.
Questions finance teams often ask
Will lenders or investors accept a specialist audit firm?
Check the relevant agreements and discuss any approval requirements with the stakeholders concerned. Do not infer acceptance or rejection from the category of firm alone.
Does partner-led mean the partner performs every part of the audit?
No. Ask how responsibilities are allocated across the engagement team and where partner involvement occurs. The important question is whether the right level of experience is applied to the work and significant judgements.
Should we change firms if we want more strategic advice?
Not necessarily. You may be able to appoint a separate adviser for a defined decision or project. First identify the support you need, then assess the appropriate scope and any independence implications.
Accendo’s approach
At Accendo, we discuss your reporting requirements, group structure, deadlines and the issues you want to address before assessing whether we are a suitable fit. We explain the proposed scope, team responsibilities and partner involvement, subject to capacity, acceptance and independence requirements.
If you are reviewing your arrangements, discuss your audit requirements. The purpose of that conversation is to establish whether there is a suitable role for Accendo, rather than assume that changing firms is the right answer.
Reviewed 21 October 2026. General guidance; the appropriate approach depends on your organisation and circumstances.
